We make handcrafted milkshakes using our small batch, super premium ice cream, with choices for thickness, mix ins and toppings, all served inside our Revolutionary War themed shop in Lehi, Utah.
Milkshakes
Our milkshakes start with one of our 32 rotating, homemade flavors. Families, couples on date night, students and visitors choose milkshakes when they want a richer, creamier dessert than a scoop alone. We balance texture, flavor and presentation so a milkshake feels like a treat and a moment to enjoy together.
If you want to learn how thickness and customization change the finished shake, see our guide on shake thickness and customization. To see where we serve the community, view our Lehi location and directions.
Benefits of choosing our milkshakes
- Small batch, super premium ice cream for a dense, creamy texture and full flavor.
- Wide flavor rotation offers classic favorites and unexpected choices from our 32 flavors.
- Custom thickness and mix ins let you tailor a shake for kids, sharing, or a decadent treat.
- Themed setting adds a playful, family friendly atmosphere that makes dessert feel like an outing.
- Menu options for birthday parties, groups and date nights to suit different occasions.
Our process for making milkshakes
- Choose a base flavor. We scoop from small batch batches of our super premium ice cream so the base flavor is rich and clear.
- Pick thickness and mix ins. You can select a thinner shake for sipping or a thicker shake meant to be eaten with a spoon, and add mix ins like sauces or cookie pieces.
- Blend to order. We blend with chilled ingredients and finish with your chosen toppings so the texture matches your selection without watering down the flavor.
- Present and enjoy. Shakes arrive topped and plated in our colonial themed setting for a memorable dessert moment.
Pro tip: Share one large shake for two people by choosing a medium thickness and asking for split toppings; it makes portioning easier and keeps the texture enjoyable.
Frequently asked questions
What flavors can I use in a milkshake?
You can use any of our rotating selection of 32 homemade flavors. Popular choices include chocolate, vanilla, salted caramel and rotating seasonal flavors. If you want a recommended pairing, ask our team which flavors mix well with a given topping.
Can I customize the shake thickness?
Yes. We offer options from drinkable to spoonable thickness. Thicker shakes use more ice cream and less liquid, while thinner shakes include more milk or a lighter base. Tell us how you prefer it and we will adjust the blend.
Do you offer milkshake toppings and mix ins?
We offer sauces, whipped cream, cookie pieces and other mix ins. Some toppings vary by season, and we can suggest combinations if you want something classic or adventurous.
Are there kid friendly shake options?
Yes. Kid friendly shakes are smaller, milder in sweetness, and can be made thinner for easy sipping. We also offer shareable sizes for families and parties.
Why choose Brookers Founding Flavors Ice Cream for milkshakes
We focus on three things that matter for a milkshake: flavor clarity, pleasing texture and a fun setting. Our small batch ice cream gives a dense, full flavor that comes through in a shake. The Revolutionary War themed decor and period costumes make a visit feel like an experience, not just a dessert stop. Families, couples and groups find the atmosphere adds to the moment.
We serve guests who want handcrafted desserts and a memorable outing, from birthday parties to casual nights out.
Service area
We are based in Lehi, Utah and proudly serve local residents and visitors from nearby communities. Common places our guests come from include Draper, American Fork, Saratoga Springs, Highland, Bluffdale, Riverton, Sandy, Orem and Provo.
Related services and further reading
Learn how our milkshakes fit into the broader menu. For build ideas and toppings, see our Sundaes page. For details on cones, cups and portioning that affect shake servings, visit our cone and cup choices guide.
Frequently asked questions
Do you have seasonal milkshake flavors?
Yes. Some flavors rotate with the season so you will find new pairings and limited time choices alongside our core flavors.
Can milkshakes be made allergy friendly?
We offer information about ingredients and can suggest options, but customers with severe allergies should consult our allergen information and consider dietary needs before ordering.
Is the shop suitable for birthday parties?
Yes. Our setting works well for small celebrations. We welcome groups and can discuss menu options for a gathering during your visit.
Find our Lehi location and learn more
Check our Google Business Profile to read reviews and get directions, and read related pages on this site to learn more about flavors, toppings and shake options.