You can make a family friendly milkshake that everyone enjoys by starting with a familiar base, adding one or two shared mix ins for texture, and letting each person pick a small topping to finish. At Brookers Founding Flavors Ice Cream, Lehi UT we recommend choosing crowd pleasing bases like vanilla or chocolate, adding a single bold mix in such as cookie dough or fresh berries, and offering a range of simple toppings so everyone from toddlers to grandparents can customize their cup.
How we think about shake toppings and mix ins for families
When families from Cedar Hills come in for a treat we plan shakes three ways, so choices are easy and the experience stays fun. First, pick a base flavor that most people like, for example our super premium vanilla or chocolate. Second, choose one or two mix ins that change texture without overwhelming the base, like cookie crumbs, malt powder, or chopped fruit. Third, offer a selection of small toppings so each person can finish their shake the way they want.
If you want more background on specific topping ideas and our in shop options, see our Shake Toppings and Mix Ins topic page for a full list of seasonal and year round choices: Shake Toppings and Mix Ins.
Toppings and mix ins that work well for mixed age groups
Kid friendly choices
Kids usually prefer bright, crunchy or sweet add ins. Try these crowd pleasers:
- Sprinkles or rainbow jimmies for color and crunch
- Mini chocolate chips or small candy pieces for a little texture
- Cookie dough chunks that are soft and familiar
Adult friendly choices
Adults often like depth and contrast. These mix ins add flavor without being too sweet:
- Bittersweet hot fudge or salted caramel sauce
- Malt powder or espresso for extra richness
- Chopped nuts or toffee for crunchy texture
Shared textures and easy compromises
When you are ordering for a group pick one mix in that changes texture but complements most flavors, for example cookie crumbs or crushed sandwich cookies. Add toppings on the side so individuals can customize their finished cup.
How to order shakes for a family group
Ordering for a family is smoother when you have a simple plan. We use group friendly options that keep wait time low and let everyone personalize.
- Pick a shared base. Choose vanilla, chocolate or another mild flavor so mix ins show through.
- Choose one main mix in. Cookie chunks, fruit compote or malt powder are good single choices to build on.
- Choose individual toppings. Offer three to five small topping options so each person can finish their own cup.
- Ask for toppings on the side. That keeps a single shake sharable and allows everyone to add what they like.
Pro tip: If you are bringing the shakes to a park in Cedar Hills, pick sturdier toppings like chopped cookies or nuts rather than delicate fruit, so the texture holds up while you walk or picnic.
Packing, sharing and bringing shakes to Cedar Hills outings
Families often want to take treats to a nearby park or picnic. Here are practical steps to keep shakes enjoyable after you leave the shop.
Packing checklist for taking shakes out
- Choose a sturdy cup and lid with a wide straw to protect texture
- Ask for sauces and fragile toppings on the side
- Bring napkins and a small cooler or insulated bag for warm days
- Plan to enjoy shakes within 30 to 60 minutes on hot days to preserve texture
Watch out: If anyone in your group has a nut allergy or other food sensitivity, tell our staff when ordering so we can separate toppings and avoid cross contact. We list common allergens at the counter and can help you choose safer options.
Mix ins and toppings by occasion
Different outings call for different choices. Here are quick pairings by occasion so you can decide fast.
- Birthday party: cookie dough mix ins, sprinkles and a drizzle of hot fudge
- Date night: espresso or malt powder with chocolate shards and caramel
- Family picnic: crushed cookies, chopped fruit on the side, and whipped cream in a separate cup
- After sports practice: a protein friendly option like peanut butter mix in a chocolate base, served in a medium cup
For more ideas on milkshake styles and thickness options see our milkshakes page: Milkshakes.
Key takeaway
Start with a familiar base, choose one shared mix in for texture, and offer small toppings on the side so every family member can personalize their shake. That approach keeps ordering simple, reduces waste, and makes group desserts more fun for everyone.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most popular family friendly shake mix ins?
Popular choices at our shop include cookie dough pieces, crushed sandwich cookies, fresh berry compote, chopped chocolate, and malt powder. These mix ins add texture and flavor without overpowering classic bases like vanilla and chocolate.
Can we share one large shake between kids and adults?
Yes, sharing works well if you ask for toppings and sauces on the side. Choose a sturdy cup and wide straw, and pick a single mix in that complements multiple palates, such as cookie crumbs or chocolate chips.
Do you handle allergies and cross contact concerns?
We list common allergens at the counter and can prepare toppings separately on request. If someone in your party has a severe allergy, tell our staff when you order so we can suggest safer options and avoid cross contact where possible.
Are there seasonal mix ins that families should try?
Yes, we rotate seasonal specialties. During summer we feature fresh berries and fruit compotes. In cooler months we add richer options like cinnamon caramel and spiced cookie mix ins. You can see current seasonal offerings on our Shake Toppings and Mix Ins topic page: Seasonal shake topping ideas.
Where is Brookers Founding Flavors Ice Cream located and do you serve Cedar Hills families?
We are Brookers Founding Flavors Ice Cream, Lehi UT. We proudly serve Lehi and nearby communities including Cedar Hills, Draper, American Fork, and Saratoga Springs. For more information about our location options and nearby areas see our locations page: Locations.
Learn more and plan your next family treat
For a full list of our topping options and seasonal choices, or to read customer notes and directions, check our Google Business Profile and our on site information. You can explore more about toppings, mix ins and related dessert topics on our site.